Maaz Zindani

Loading the index…

↑↓ move↵ openesc close4072 pages

Buyer guide

C2C, W-2 or 1099: how do the three arrangements differ for an employer?

In short

W-2 means the person is your employee and you run payroll. 1099 means you contract with the individual, who handles their own tax. C2C means you contract with their company. None of the labels decides the status: the facts of the working relationship do. Check your case with an accountant.

  • Written for founders and business owners
  • Updated
  • By Maaz Zindani, Senior Software Engineer

Who is this guide for?

Employers, hiring managers and recruiters who are choosing how to engage a software engineer in the United States and want the differences laid out before they speak to an accountant or lawyer.

W-2: the person is your employee

An employee is paid through payroll. The employer normally withholds income tax and employment taxes, pays its own share of employment taxes and carries the other duties of an employer. The IRS publishes the details under employment taxes.

This suits a long-term role where you direct how, when and where the work is done. It is the heaviest to set up and the easiest to defend as a classification.

1099: you contract with an individual

An independent contractor is in business for themselves. You pay for a result or a service, you do not withhold tax and the contractor handles their own. Payments to individual contractors are generally reported on a Form 1099 series return; which form and when depends on the facts, so ask your accountant.

This suits a defined piece of work with a person who sets their own methods and hours. It carries the classification risk if you manage the person like staff.

C2C: you contract with the person's company

In a corp-to-corp arrangement the agreement and invoices run between your company and the contractor's company. The contractor's company handles its own tax, insurance and benefits.

The word corp is loose. The IRS explains that an LLC can be taxed as a sole proprietorship, partnership or corporation, so how the contractor's company is taxed is a separate question from the contract.

Control decides, not the label

The IRS describes three groups of evidence: behavioural control, financial control and the relationship of the parties. The US Department of Labor applies its own test under the Fair Labor Standards Act, and the states have theirs.

A contractor who works under your daily direction, on your schedule, with your equipment and for one client only can look like an employee under any of the three labels. Moving the label from 1099 to C2C does not by itself change that.

Questions to put to your accountant or lawyer

Ask which tests apply in your state, what forms you must file for each arrangement, whether the specific working pattern you have in mind looks like employment and what the consequences of misclassification are. The IRS also offers a way for a business or a worker to ask for a determination of status, and a voluntary programme for reclassifying workers.

Rules differ by country. If the contractor or the client is outside the United States, the local rules matter too.

How do the options compare?

W-21099C2C
Who you sign withThe person, as employeeThe person, as individual contractorThe person's company
Payroll and withholdingEmployer runs itNot run by the clientNot run by the client
Who pays for tools, insurance, benefitsUsually the employerThe contractorThe contractor's company
Typical useOngoing role under your directionDefined work by an individualDefined service from a company
Main thing to watchCost and duties of employmentMisclassification if you direct the workMisclassification, and what the company really is

What should I check before I sign?

  • You know which of the three arrangements the requirement really is.
  • The working pattern matches the arrangement: direction and hours for W-2, a service and a scope for contracting.
  • You have asked an accountant which forms and withholding apply.
  • You have read the IRS and Department of Labor guidance on classification.
  • The contract does not contradict how the work will actually run.
  • You know who owns the work product.
  • You have checked the rules in the contractor's country if they are not in yours.

How pricing works

I quote in writing after a short discovery call, against a written scope. Building an app from scratch? The app cost calculator gives a first range in two minutes.

What else do people ask?

Is C2C safer than 1099 for an employer?

Not automatically. The classification question rests on the facts of the relationship in both cases. Take advice on your own arrangement.

Can the same engineer be offered W-2, 1099 or C2C?

Many job posts offer more than one. The legal status then depends on how each is set up, so each needs its own paperwork and its own check.

Who pays for equipment under C2C?

Normally the contractor's company, but the contract decides. If the client supplies accounts and tools, say so in writing and check the effect on classification.

Do I need a lawyer for this?

For a first C2C engagement, a short review by an accountant or employment lawyer in your state is a sensible step before you commit.

Sources

How was this page made?

I drafted this page with AI assistance from the official documents listed under Sources. Found a mistake? Tell me.

How can we work this way together?

Next step

Want a written quote to compare?

A discovery call within 48 hours, then a scope and a price in writing.