Help for owners
Apple rejected my app as spam, or for being incomplete or for privacy
Short answer
Each number means something different. 4.3 says your app duplicates another or is indistinguishable from what is widely available. 2.1 says it was incomplete, crashed or the reviewer could not log in. 5.1.1 is about your privacy policy and consent. Find your number in the message, fix that exact point and reply in App Store Connect.
Does this sound like your situation?
- The message says Guideline 4.3 and the word spam.
- Apple says my app is incomplete, crashed or has placeholder content.
- The message mentions privacy, consent or my privacy policy.
- I resubmitted and got the same number again.
- My developer says the rejection is wrong.
Why does this happen?
4.3(a): the same app under many bundle IDs
Apple says not to create multiple Bundle IDs of the same app, for example a separate map app for every city. If an app has different versions for locations, sports teams or universities, Apple suggests submitting one app and providing the variations using in-app purchase.
Confirmed by developer.apple.comTechnical detail: Apple rejected the app under Guideline 4.3, Design: Spam
4.3(b): too close to what is already on the store
Apple says not to submit apps that are indistinguishable from what is already widely available. It names dating, flashlight, sound effects, wallpaper, simple timers and fortune telling as established kinds that it will not accept unless they offer a meaningfully different or improved experience.
Confirmed by developer.apple.com
2.1: the reviewer could not use the app
Apple says submissions should be final versions with all metadata and working URLs, no placeholder text, and demo account information, with your back-end service turned on, if the app has a login. It says it will reject incomplete bundles and binaries that crash or show obvious technical problems.
Confirmed by developer.apple.com
5.1.1: privacy policy and consent
Apple says every app must link to its privacy policy in the App Store Connect metadata and within the app, and that apps collecting user or usage data must secure the user's consent.
Confirmed by developer.apple.com
What can I do about it today?
- Find the exact number in the message4.3, 2.1 and 5.1.1 need different fixes, and the part in brackets, such as (a) or (b), matters. Do not treat them as one problem.
- Do not resubmit the same buildApple says not to resubmit until every issue it identified is resolved, because resubmitting with unresolved issues delays review and produces the same outcome.
- For 2.1, test what the reviewer sawInstall the build fresh, log in with the demo account you gave, and make sure the server is switched on and no page is empty.
- For 5.1.1, open the privacy policy in the app and in App Store ConnectBoth places must show a working link. The policy must say what data you collect and how it is used. Ask a lawyer to check the wording of the policy.
- Reply before you resubmit when it is only a questionApple says not to resubmit when App Review only needs more information. Use Reply to App Review in App Store Connect, and ask for a call if you need one.
- Appeal only if you believe the app compliesApple's appeal route is for rejections you believe follow the guidelines, after you have replied. Do not file an appeal if you have already fixed the issue and resubmitted.
When should I bring someone in?
- The rejection is 4.3 and your app is built from a template or one codebase for many clients.
- The same number returns after you fixed what you believed was wrong.
- The app collects data and you are not sure what the privacy text and consent screens must contain.
How do I handle it?
- Match the number to the problemI read the cited guideline and your submission and say which part of the app the reviewer is talking about.
- Reproduce the reviewer's pathA clean install, your demo account and the exact version, checking for crashes, empty screens, dead links and missing consent.
- Fix the cause, then write the replyI make the change and draft a factual reply, with an appeal text only if the rejection still looks wrong.
- Leave the verdict to AppleApple decides. I make sure each submission answers the stated reason, and I do not promise approval.
The price depends on what I find, so I quote in writing after a short discovery call. Tell me what is happening and I reply within 24 hours.
What do owners ask about this?
Is 4.3 a ban on my account?
The guideline text says repeated submissions of low-quality kinds may lead to removal from the Apple Developer Program. A single rejection is not that, but it should be taken seriously.
My app is original, why 4.3?
Apple's wording looks at whether it is distinguishable from what is widely available, and at multiple Bundle IDs of the same app. The cause is often the template or the number of listings, not your idea.
Can I reply instead of changing anything?
If the reviewer misunderstood the app, Apple suggests explaining its concept and intended functionality in the reply. If the guideline was met, you can then appeal.
How is this different from the general rejection page?
That page covers any rejection. This one is about the three numbers owners meet most: 4.3, 2.1 and 5.1.1.
Sources
How was this page made?
I drafted this page with AI assistance from the official documents listed under Sources. Found a mistake? Tell me.