Maaz Zindani

Loading the index…

↑↓ move↵ openesc close4072 pages

Help for owners

I am moving my store from BigCommerce to Shopify and things are going wrong

Short answer

Shopify's own guide says to import products first, then customers, then past orders, that some data cannot move by file, and that old links break unless redirects are set up before the domain moves. Keep the BigCommerce store running until test orders work on the new one.

  • Written for business owners
  • Updated
  • By Maaz Zindani, Senior Software Engineer

Does this sound like your situation?

  • Orders came across but they are not linked to the right products or customers.
  • Some of my data, such as gift cards or custom fields, did not arrive.
  • Google results for my old product pages now show an error.
  • My staff get a flood of new-order emails while the import runs.
  • Something that worked on BigCommerce, such as an integration or a custom checkout step, has no obvious match.

Why does this happen?

  1. The data has to arrive in order

    Shopify says to import products first, then customers, then historical orders, so that orders connect to the right products and customers. An import run in a different order, or repeated, leaves orders pointing at nothing.

  2. Not everything can travel in a file

    Shopify's guide says some data cannot be migrated through CSV files and suggests an app, the API or copying by hand for those. Pages such as shipping or refund policies can usually be copied and pasted.

  3. Old links change

    Shopify says its link structure for pages is likely different from your previous platform, so old links may break. It advises setting up URL redirects before the domain is transferred, and a redirect file can be imported.

  4. Some addresses cannot be redirected

    Shopify says a redirect only works from an address that is broken, and that paths starting with /apps, /cart, /orders or /shop, and fixed paths such as /products and /collections, cannot be redirected.

  5. The store is more than its products

    Theme, shipping rates, taxes, payment provider, checkout settings and staff accounts all have to be set up again in Shopify. Anything custom that your old store did, and anything connected to it, needs a new route.

What can I do about it today?

  1. Keep the BigCommerce store runningDo not switch the domain or cancel anything until the new store has taken test orders and you have checked them.
  2. Stop repeating the importIf an import went wrong, do not run it again to see what happens. Write down what is missing or doubled and ask whoever ran it how to clean up first.
  3. Make a list of your best-selling pagesCopy the web addresses of your top products, categories and pages. This list is what the redirects are built from.
  4. Turn off staff order emails before importing ordersShopify notes that staff set to receive new-order notifications get an email for each imported order, and that you can turn them off before importing and on again afterwards.
  5. List what is connected to the old storeAccounting, shipping, stock, email and any custom checkout step. Each one needs a named owner and a plan on the new store.
  6. Place real test ordersOrder a cheap item yourself and follow it through payment, email and fulfilment before announcing the new store.

When should I bring someone in?

  • Orders, customers or products are missing or duplicated and you are not sure which copy is right.
  • Search traffic drops after the switch and old addresses show errors.
  • Integrations, such as stock or accounting, stopped at the moment of the move.

How do I handle it?

  1. Inventory the old storeI list what the store holds and does: products and options, customers, orders, apps, scripts and every system it talks to.
  2. Map each item to a routeFor each item I decide whether it moves by file, by API, by an app or by hand, using Shopify's guide, and which cannot move at all.
  3. Build the redirect list firstOld addresses are matched to new ones before the domain moves, and tested one by one.
  4. Rehearse on a copyI run the import on a test store, compare counts and sample records against the original, and fix the mapping before the real run.
  5. Switch with a way backThe old store stays intact until the new one has handled real orders. I connect the integrations on the new store and check them.

The price depends on what I find, so I quote in writing after a short discovery call. Tell me what is happening and I reply within 24 hours.

What do owners ask about this?

Do customer passwords move across?

Shopify's migration guide covers importing customer data but does not say that passwords carry over. Plan for customers to need a way to set a new password, and check Shopify's current wording before you promise anything to them.

Can I move everything with a CSV file?

No. Shopify says some data cannot be migrated through CSV files, and recommends an app, the API or copying by hand for those.

Will my Google ranking survive the move?

I cannot promise that, because search engines decide. Redirects from every old address to its new page, set up before the domain moves, are the main thing within your control.

Sources

How was this page made?

I drafted this page with AI assistance from the official documents listed under Sources. Found a mistake? Tell me.

Next step

Want this off your desk?

Send me a few lines on where things stand. I reply within 24 hours.