Help for owners
I bought a password manager but my staff will not use it
Short answer
Adoption fails when the manager is harder than the habit it replaces. Pick one tool that works on every device people use, move the shared accounts in for them, protect it with two-step verification, and make a manager entry the only place an approved login lives. Staff stop sharing in chat once the manager is quicker.
Does this sound like your situation?
- People installed it once and went back to the old spreadsheet or chat.
- Shared logins are still pasted in messages.
- Staff say it is slow, it does not fill the right fields, or it is not on their phone.
- Only a few people, usually me, have actually moved accounts into it.
- When someone asks for a login, the answer is still a text message.
Why does this happen?
The manager does not work where staff work
The NCSC says to choose a manager by whether it works across your devices and operating systems. A tool that is awkward on a phone or a shared workstation will be skipped.
Confirmed by ncsc.gov.uk
Nobody moved the existing logins in
An empty manager is no use. If staff have to copy each shared login themselves, they keep using the old list until they must.
Autofill issues look like the tool being broken
The NCSC notes autofill only fills passwords on the correct website. When a login page uses an unusual address, staff see a failure and fall back to pasting.
Confirmed by ncsc.gov.uk
The main password is a single point of failure
The NCSC says to remember the primary password and to turn on two-step verification for the manager. Staff who forget it, with no recovery plan, stop trusting the tool.
Confirmed by ncsc.gov.uk
No rule says where logins live
If chat and spreadsheets remain acceptable, they stay in use. Habits change when there is one agreed place and a clear person who sets it up.
What can I do about it today?
- Ask three people what stops themShort, friendly questions: which device, which login, what went wrong. The answers are usually practical and quick to fix.
- Move the shared logins in yourselfPut the accounts staff use daily into the manager and share them with the right people, so the first thing they see is useful.
- Set up each person on the devices they usePhone, laptop and shared machines. Do it with them for ten minutes rather than sending instructions.
- Turn on two-step verification for the managerThe NCSC advises it, so a leaked main password alone cannot open the whole vault.
- Agree one ruleApproved logins live in the manager, not in chat or files. Tell people what to do if the manager fails to fill.
- Remove the old routeWhen the spreadsheet is empty, delete it, so there is nothing left to fall back on.
When should I bring someone in?
- Staff need logins for systems that do not work with autofill, such as internal tools or servers.
- You cannot tell which accounts are still shared outside the manager.
- The business needs separate users for services that only offer a single login.
How do I handle it?
- Find the specific frictionI watch or ask how each role signs in, and list the logins that break autofill or have no way to be shared safely.
- Fix those firstAwkward logins get their own entries or are replaced with named accounts, so the manager is faster than chat.
- Set it up around rolesGroups and shared folders follow the roles you have, with a named owner for each shared account.
- Keep recovery boring and safeWho can reset a forgotten main password, where recovery details live and how a leaver is removed are agreed up front.
- Check usage after a monthA short review of which accounts are still outside the manager and why.
The price depends on what I find, so I quote in writing after a short discovery call. Tell me what is happening and I reply within 24 hours.
What do owners ask about this?
Should I make it compulsory?
Set it as the agreed rule once it works well. A rule on a tool that is slow only pushes the old habit out of sight.
What if staff resist because it is one more thing?
Show the time saved: no asking for logins, no resets. The NCSC lists autofill and not having to remember passwords as benefits.
Is it riskier to put everything in one place?
The manager is protected by a main password and two-step verification, which the NCSC advises. A spreadsheet has neither.
Can it work for shared accounts?
Many managers offer sharing. The NCSC lists secure password sharing as an extra to check when choosing.
Sources
How was this page made?
I drafted this page with AI assistance from the official documents listed under Sources. Found a mistake? Tell me.