Maaz Zindani

Loading the index…

↑↓ move↵ openesc close4072 pages

Help for owners

My Shopify subscription customers are not being charged on renewal

Short answer

Renewals fail for a few separate reasons: the customer's payment method was declined, a product had no stock, or a second subscription app and your own settings disagree. In the Subscriptions app's Billing attempts settings you choose how many retries happen and what follows when they all fail. Start by listing which renewals actually missed.

  • Written for business owners
  • Updated
  • By Maaz Zindani, Senior Software Engineer

Does this sound like your situation?

  • Some customers say they were not charged and no order arrived.
  • Others say they were charged twice.
  • I see subscriptions skipped, paused or cancelled that nobody touched.
  • Renewal orders appear in the app but never in my fulfilment tool.
  • Failed payments pile up and I do not know who to contact.

Why does this happen?

  1. The customer's card failed

    Cards expire, get replaced or are declined by the bank. Customers with accounts can update their payment method in their customer account, but they only do it if they know the charge failed.

  2. Retries and the final action are settings you control

    In the Billing attempts section of the Subscriptions app settings you can change the number of retry attempts and the days between them. When all retries fail you choose whether the subscription is skipped, paused or cancelled, and the customer receives a notification either way. A setting that was never reviewed can quietly cancel people.

  3. Stock counts as a failure

    The same retry settings apply when a subscription product has no stock, not only when a payment is declined. The app also lets you choose whether subscription products track inventory, which changes what happens when stock runs out.

  4. Emails are on by default, but check who sees them

    Subscription email notifications are on by default, and customer and staff notifications can be switched on or off separately under Settings, Notifications. If staff notifications went to a mailbox nobody reads, failures stay unseen.

  5. Other apps and flows read the same orders

    A store sometimes has a second subscription app, a loyalty tool or a fulfilment connector reading the same renewals. They can duplicate, change or block an order, and the cause is not in the subscription app at all.

What can I do about it today?

  1. Make a list before changing anythingExport the last renewal period's orders and the subscription list. Mark who was charged, who failed and who is missing.
  2. Look at the Billing attempts settingsNote how many retries and how many days apart, and what happens after the last one: skip, pause or cancel. Write the current values down before you change them.
  3. Check stock on subscription productsIf a product reaches zero, renewals for it can fail even though cards are fine.
  4. Check the notification settingsConfirm that staff notifications reach a real inbox, and that customer emails are on, so customers learn their card failed.
  5. Contact the affected customers yourselfA short personal email asking them to update their payment method in their account recovers many failed renewals, and it avoids guessing.
  6. Do not disable or reinstall the app to testRemoving a subscription app can affect existing subscriptions. Ask the app's support before you try that.

When should I bring someone in?

  • Renewals fail for customers whose cards are good.
  • Two apps are involved and you cannot tell which one created an order.
  • Money was charged without an order, or an order was created without a charge.

How do I handle it?

  1. Reconcile one renewal cycleI line up subscriptions, charges and orders for a single cycle, so the list of missed or duplicated renewals is a fact and not a feeling.
  2. Trace one failed renewal end to endFrom the schedule, to the charge attempt, to the order, to fulfilment, I look for where the record stops.
  3. Read the settings and the other appsRetry rules, inventory tracking, notifications and any other app touching renewals are compared with what you intend.
  4. Fix in a safe orderSettings first, then connectors or custom code, with notes on what was changed and how to undo it.
  5. Add a simple weekly checkA short report of failed and skipped renewals so problems reach a person before customers write.

The price depends on what I find, so I quote in writing after a short discovery call. Tell me what is happening and I reply within 24 hours.

What do owners ask about this?

Will you rebuild the subscription logic?

Usually the cause is a setting, a card or a second app. I look at those before suggesting code.

Can I charge the customers again?

Only with their agreement and through the payment tools you are already using. Ask them to update their payment method instead of retrying blindly.

How do I stop customers cancelling after failed charges?

Review the action taken after the last retry. You can choose skip, pause or cancel, and the customer is notified in each case.

Does this apply to other subscription tools?

The checks are similar, but retry rules differ, so I read each tool's own documentation.

Sources

How was this page made?

I drafted this page with AI assistance from the official documents listed under Sources. Found a mistake? Tell me.

Next step

Want this off your desk?

Send me a few lines on where things stand. I reply within 24 hours.